Kristy Lee Cook - FOREVER - Mariah Carey -Final-7 04/15/2008

ok she was my favorite girl in the show im pissed my favorite guy is david cook but i like kristy more i wanted her to win BUT they just lost a fan of the show specially after how they treated kristy THAT was mean

OK Simon you could atleast buy her horse

Actually thought is was one of her best !!!!

I seriously think that Kristy sings better than Brooke.Kristy is a good singer

oh my God, that's so disgusting... u freak!

SHE'S HOT AS HELL!

I think she is so hot...my fantasy is to have her not wash her hair for two weeks and then smell it.

i loved you i wanted you to win i hope you get your horses

Brooke S**ks . she can't sing HIGH NOTES like KRISTY LEE COOK. I CAN'T BLIEVE simon CHOSE Brooke OVER KRISTY! seems simon's not fond of pretty girls. MAYBE CUZ HIS GIRLFRIEND TERRY IS NOT SO pretty.

prettiest idol girls:

KRISTY LEE COOK
KAT MCPHEE
HALEY SCARNATO
CARRIE UNDERWOOD

in fairness this is her best song.... all of the other S**ks

she should come right back brooke should have gone she is really bad KRISTY LEE COOK IS THE ONLY REALLY GOOD GIRL SINGER ON AMERICAN IDOL

Brooke is S**ks kristy rocks
that is all

Me too. Her Beatles song (8 days a week) was hiddeous! Why they elimated Shikeze (I don't remember how to spell his name) that day instead of her is beyond me.

MARIAH CAREY OWNS!!!

Brooke should've gone...I've been listening to KLC's performances lately! I think they were great!

I was screaming in joy that she left! She butchered Beatles songs which is unforgivable and it just all went down hill. She should have gone home a looong time ago!

pales in comparison, but she did ok.

i think she song country music version of mariah carey song...very disappointing

shut up simon!!!!!

oh man... she definitely should stay... :(.. in my opinion carly is the one who should go.. kristy.. shes a whole package!

AND THAT ARCULETA IS A F****t IM TELLIN YOU!! HAVE YOU SEEN HIS PERFORMANCE IN A TALENT SHOW WHEN HE SANG "IMAGINE" WHEN HE'S 12? whatta gay-ass!! AI shouldn't let that F****t in the show...he's obviously faking his gay-voice thats why it's so big and unnatural..he's trying to make his voice masculine but he's caught! F****t ass-archuleta!!!!

idiot!! she shouldn't have gone because she's way better than brooke!!you assholes hate her cause she's beautiful, sexy, great blowing voice and has a big potential in show business! y'all just insecure coz that smithson is a pig and like a bar performer and the negra is being a soul-N****r singer wannbee, but she isn't!! and brooke white? trying to be unique but she's a trash and a S**k up plastic bitch..not that im being mean or something.. hahahahah!

idiot!! she shouldn't have gone because she's way better than brooke!!you assholes hate her cause she's beautiful, sexy, great blowing voice and has a big potential in show business! y'all just insecure coz that smithson is a pig and like a bar performer and the negra is being a soul-N****r singer wannbee, but she isn't!! and brooke white? trying to be unique but she's a trash and a S**k up plastic bitch..not that im being mean or something.. hahahahah!

That was horrible, she sings way too slow. Glad she finally got voted off, good riddance!

no offense for the fans of her..but i think that she didnt sing that very well in this song..and unfortunately its not her luck as Americans didnt voted her to stay...